A young demon who looks to gain control of the underworld suspects that the sisters are still alive and devises a plan to lure them out of hiding that involves plot lines from the story of Alice in Wonderland. However, it doesn't take long for Billie to realize what the demon is up to and goes after him by herself, only to become a victim as well and as a result, the sisters have to risk exposure to save her. Paige contemplates becoming a cop after being pulled over and Phoebe, in her new persona, is hired at the paper as the new advice columnist.